12 Comments »

Youth Cup report and player ratings: An Arsenal team that scores four and wins

PLAYER RATINGS……

1. JAMES SHEA – Looks small and slight, but rarely troubled all night and commanded his box like a young Shay Given – 7.5

2. CRAIG EASTMOND – got forward well, passed accurately and astutely, made goal-saving tackles and interceptions, genuinely looked the part – 8

3. THOMAS CRUISE – tidy and controlled, and his central defenders were noticeably more confortable with him than his replacement Evina, but not much to get excited about – 6

4. EMMANUEL FRIMPONG – hard to tell what he’s like given his early booking, but frankly looked like a chunkier Eboue on one of Eboue’s less effective days – 5

5. KYLE BARTLEY – complete control in the air, one goal and one assist, vocal with his team-mates and marshalled a strong defence: you can’t ask for more – 8

6. LUKE AYLING – strong throughout and stepped up as traffic down the left-hand side increased in the second half. Decent distribution and a no-fuss performance – 7

7. JACK WILSHERE – the criticism of him not bothering with these games is unfounded: he got well stuck in, but he couldn’t get enough time on the ball to pull the strings – 6

8. FRANCIS COQUELIN – he works like Flamini, passes like Davis and tackles like Petit, but he disappears like Nasri and as a result, we didn’t see enough as we’d like – 6.5

9. GILLES SUNU – anonymous really – worked hard and snapped one over the bar after good work, but not really his game and was subbed late on – 5

10. SANCHEZ WATT – utterly brilliant, never stopped running, scored 2 goals and won a penalty through sheer persistence and pace, but showed a lot else besides – 8.5

11. JAY-EMMANUEL THOMAS – great pass for the opener, in cruise control after that, occasional bursts of brilliance and pace, but this was not a game which he needed to boss so he didn’t boss it – 6

12. CEDRIC EVINA (79 mins) – clearly pacy, but in his rush to make an impression, he seemed to annoy Ayling and Bartley, who wanted to keep the defence in shape – good! – 5

13. BENIK AFOBE (79 mins) – did what Sunu didn’t, operated direct down the middle and obviously had the pace to worry the defenders – 6

14. LUKE FREEMAN (89 mins) – hardly got a touch but was the only Arsenal player to do a Bendtner and head straight down the tunnel at the whistle – 4

15. OZAGUN OZAKYUP (Not Used) – in contrast to Freeman, he warmed up properly throughout, gave no dissent when it was obvious he wouldn’t come on, and then went onto the pitch at the end to shake hands with all his team-mates and applaud the Arsenal fans. For attitude alone, it’s clear why he’s the Dutch youth captain.

Goodplaya writes: I chickened out of this one on the premise that three Arsenal matches in five days might test even my very easy going girlfriend’s patience. This comes from our special correspondent.

Youth Cup semi-final second leg at the Emirates
Arsenal 4 Man City 1 (6-2 agg)

A VERY entertaining night at The Emirates to see Arsenal ease through the second leg of the FA Youth Cup semi final, 4-1 on the night, making it 6-2 on aggregate after a much tougher night away at Man City.

Tickets were available at £10 from a well-staffed box office right up to kick off, and I was one of many who turned up by chance having seen the crowds of kids in Arsenal shirts milling down Holloway Road.

Three sides of the lower tier were opened up on a first-come, first-sat basis and most of us opted for a central view from the East and West stands. The North stand filled up as Arsenal attacked it in the second half, and by the end, it looked a much bigger crowd than the 9,500 announced as the official attendance.

Particular praise for the gaggle of 300-or-so mostly teenage boys and girls who formed an impromptu singing section in the far corner of the North stand, on their feet throughout, keeping up almost constant bursts of ‘Red Army’ and ‘Stand Up If You Hate Tottenham’, and teaching lots of bad words to the hundreds of primary age kids in attendance.

Arsenal got off to a perfect start after a minute when skipper Jay Emmanuel Thomas curled a long pass over the top, the City keeper retreated onto his line (think Stuart Taylor against Riise), and Sanchez Watt beat the defenders to slash the ball in for 1-0.

Whether that gave him confidence or not, Watt was utterly brilliant for the rest of the night, whereas – strangely – J-E Thomas (or JET as the kids call him) looked as though his work was done, and coasted through the last 89 minutes.

City came back strongly, but the Arsenal defence looked and felt like a Steve Bould creation: a chevron formation, with Kyle Bartley and Luke Ayling doing a passable imitation of Bould and Adams themselves.

And like the Bould-Adams back four, whenever the line was breached, the four defenders tore back like Banshees and crunched into clearing tackles and interceptions. The contrast with Tuesday night’s effort at Anfield couldn’t have been bigger.

I was looking forward to seeing Emmanuel Frimpong, but he had a bizarre night. He made two awful late tackles on dangerous City midfielder Ibrahim in the first ten minutes, and finally got a yellow card for the third. After that, he did very little bar the odd unproductive charge out of midfield. I kept thinking Eboue as I watched him, and not in the occasionally good way.

On the positive side, Bartley – who is tall but has some growing out to do, like a young Rio Ferdinand – then set up the second goal with another beautifully-weighted long ball over the top. Sanchez Watt again got to it first and was knocked arse-over-tit by the keeper. A penalty but no card.

Jack Wilshere – quiet up to that point – seemed to wave away either some advice or a request to take the kick from J-E Thomas, and slapped it in to the keeper’s left.

Wilshere then curled in a lovely corner with his left foot, this after equally lovely work on the right from Francis Coquelin, and Bartley headed in for 3-0.

Quickly afterwards, Watt got his reward for literally non-stop hassling of the City defence, nicking the ball off their left back, sprinting into the box and firing under the keeper for his second.

As well as having a fantastic work ethic, huge energy, two good feet, incredible pace, a great pass, and a decent spring for headers, Watt is clearly a natural finisher. He’s a bit like the very young (Makita tournament) Andy Cole, but a bit like Cole, he may be one of those players who needs to have a good day to have a good day.

So, 4-0 up after 30 minutes, and unlike their first-team counterparts, there was not the slightest chance of this Arsenal team shipping 4 goals at the other end. Not that City didn’t attack well or have chances, but just that this Bouldie-managed Back Four defended like demons.

Particularly impressive was right back Craig Eastmond. Bad things have occasionally been said about him on the various youth team blogs, but however he’s played in the past, he was exceptional last night and looked a very healthy chip off the Cole, Clichy, Gibbs block.

He and Bartley made for an impenetrable right side of the defence, and it was no wonder City turned all their attack onto the left side after the break, putting Thomas Cruise and Ayling through a tough second half.

City got one back on 46 minutes, and there was lots of work for the defence and keeper to do after that, as the midfield and forwards – bar Watt and Coquelin – took it easy with the tie won.

Wilshere had a late flurry, whizzing one over the bar, and showing he could work for the team by chasing down the City right back and taking a clearance in the face.

People say Wilshere doesn’t shine in these youth games because he isn’t up for it enough. Bollocks. The difference is that in these games he’s too often having to control bouncing balls or contest possession to get any time on the ball, compared to the first team – when it’s laid on a platter for him by the likes of Fabregas.

It was plain sailing to the final whistle, after which we enjoyed the pleasant sight of the Arsenal youngsters taking a lazy lap of honour before dissolving happily into the arms of their mates and family near the dugouts.

A word about the Arsenal manager Steve Bould. He barely came out of the dugout area all match, but it was noticeable when he did that it was usually to upbraid the defence over some lapse. And the players listened to him. They were well-drilled and knew enough about each other’s roles to have a go at each other for any perceived failing. I’m off to the bookies tomorrow to ask about the odds on Bouldie to succeed Arsene.

It was a jolly atmosphere coming away from the ground. Lovely to see 13-year olds who maybe don’t always get to go see the first team finding it hilarious and novel to ask each other: ‘What do you think of Tottenham?’, ‘What do you think of shit?’……About 60 times. Just like we did a few years ago. Great days.

12 Responses to “Youth Cup report and player ratings: An Arsenal team that scores four and wins”

  1. A bit harsh on Frimpong who I thought settled down well after an over-enthusiastic hacking start – and Coquelin looks the business to me. Odd that JET was so casual all night – after his superb through ball after 30 seconds….I know it is his style but hope he can knuckle down and make the most of his obvious talent.

  2. H_Van_Smeiter

    Who is the mystery correspondent? He or she has a lovely writing style. I loved the imagery used here:

    ‘It was plain sailing to the final whistle, after which we enjoyed the pleasant sight of the Arsenal youngsters taking a lazy lap of honour before dissolving happily into the arms of their mates and family near the dugouts.’

  3. Thanks Goodplaya. The report was really useful, and like Smeiter above, I love the writing style of your reporting friend. From many youth reports, Coquelin is going to be a great aquisition. One question though, why doesn’t Bould work with the first team’s back five? They look like they use some lessons in dfending.

  4. good play from the kids! happy 4 them

  5. As a visiting spurs fan who watched the game as my mates son plays for Citeh it was sad and childish to see adults joining in imbeclic chants of the kids. Strange also bcos as a season ticket holder at the Lane we dont refer to you unless we play you or your losing at half time.
    Thought Watts Thomas Coquelin and OShea had stand out games but Citeh were poor in the 1st half maybe nerves and pressure were the cause. Still think Amoo and Ecclestone will cause problems for your full-backs.

  6. Firmly believe that JET is going to be a hell of a player in the future. Watched the guy’s ability being appreciated in he past year. From virtual sweeper throw midfield to playing in hole in less than a year. This guys got such potential, an absolutely outstanding all round player that is a club that will get the best out of him. Still very young but what potential>>

  7. Yep, great report.

    I am particularly interested in the development of Kyle Bartley. Sounds very promising.

    What has happened to Nordveit? I remember reading he went back to Norway on loan…?

    I also think Coquelin will make the first team before JET.

  8. “15 months after our stunning win against Arsenal’s school team, the Spurs club shop are proud to present a thrilling DVD of our incredible first half win at Manchester United.” Get it here:

    http://tinyurl.com/spudsdvd

  9. Did the visting Spuds fan Mr Repesh really say that they only mention the Mighty Arsenal if they’re playing us or if we’re losing? I find this extremley difficult to believe, your obsession with all things red and white is hilariously famous

  10. Enjoyment of the game was pretty much spoiled by the behavior of Jay Emmanuel Thomas. He obviously believes his own publicity and wandered around, literally walking or standing most of the time, as though everyone else should pass to him and then him, and only him would do something special. In variably when he did get the ball he then tried some showboating which came to nothing. The rest of the team worked hard to great effect but, jeez, this guy, the captain, was disgraceful. It culminated in an obnoxious episode where rather than shake the hand of a city player at the final whistle he put six fingers up in front of his face and turned his back on the city player. The ref saw it and booked him, even though the agem had finished. This guy is a complete prat and we don’t want him as Arsenal with an attitude like that.

  11. Alexander, Norway

    To Sniff: Håvard Nordtveit is playing in the Norwegian Premier League for Lillestrøm, who is now coached by former Man Utd- and Blackburn defender Henning Berg. One of the most talented coaches in Norway, he fielded a team against mighty Rosenborg this evening with a team consisting of four 17-18 year olds.

    Nordtveit is a regular so far, and according to myself and experts he has taken the league VERY well. He is actually playing right back as they have to monsters and former (/current) norwegian internationals there, but I believe he played central in matchday two.

    So there is no need to worry about Nordtveit. He is looking absolutely brilliant. Steady, very difficult to get past, and is also surprisingly efficient on the ball (not like ordinary teenage centre halves). A future international for sure, and for Arsenal, no question.

  12. Not sure that this is true:), but thanks for a post.
    Have a nice day