THERE were a few stories of this Emirates Cup.
Perhaps the most far reaching is the all but confirmation that we are moving to a 4-3-3 formation. We saw it for 90 minutes in both games, to go on top of in the other friendlies. The good news, in my view, is that it does NOT seem to consist of Cesc Fabregas playing as a second striker.
We saw that at the end of last season and I didn’t like it one bit. Instead, the trio in the middle are far more fluid, with Cesc given licence to operate from deep, collecting the ball from Almunia at times and spraying passes around.
Jack Wilshere was another story. He played a game and a half and was outstanding for a game and a half. And there will be those who will contrast the 66 minutes RVP and Bendtner played against Athletico with the final third of that game and the majority of the Rangers game and conclude that the two aforementioned players slow the team down.
There may be a little truth in it, but consider too that it was Cesc and Wilshere as opposed to Denilson and Eboue offering the support on Sunday and the argument becomes less clear cut. What I think is beyond doubt is that while Cesc, Wilshere, Arshavin, Eduardo, Merida and Song played some beautiful stuff, we wre physically minute and the likes of RVP and Bendtner can offer crucial physical presence.
So, onto the player ratings and apologies in advance if any of my recollections are less than 100% accurate. It was Mannone (6) on Saturday and frankly he looked shaky when Rangers attacked late on, with one swerving shot almost embarrassing him in a way it might have been hard to recover from. Almunia (7) looked better against Rangers and pulled off one good save with his legs from close range.
Bacary Sagna (7.5) bombed forward from right-back against Athletico, even if his crossing was a bit hit and miss. Comrade Eboue (7), our only other right-back, looked better in that position on the Sunday than right-wing for 45 minutes on the Saturday. I can hardly believe I’m saying this, but actually I don’t know if I want him to leave.
Firstly, we lack any cover at right-back. And secondly, when he doesn’t roll around and dive and moan and play the clown and lose concentration, he’s actually a decent footballer.
William Gallas (7.5) looked solid and increasingly vital in his game and a half. Johan Djourou (7) was fine, even if at times in both games we looked a little shambolic. Silvestre (6) did little to change any already arrived at opinions.
Armand Traore (6.5) was fine in his two halfs but didn’t do enough in my view to push himself ahead of Gibbs. Gael Clichy (6.5) looked rusty but it was good to have him back.
Aaron Ramsey (7.5) dinked a beautiful ball across for Wilshere’s second against Rangers and generally looked interested. Alex Song 7.5 looked strong both in defence and midfield against Rangers and outshone the lacking in confidence Denilson (6), in keeping with the end of last season.
Cesc (7.5) linked beautifully at times with Arshavin, while Merida (7.5) was something of an unexpected hit for me, using the ball very well at times and not looking out of place. Meanwhile Tomas Rosicky (8) gets high marks for a very impressive return. Denied a very nice goal against Madrid, 63 minutes over the two games was a nice contribution and having him available as part of our middle three would be a boost.
Sanchez Watt (7.5) was only on for a little while but made Wilshere’s second with terrific chasing down of what appeared a lost cause. Wilshere (9) brought the Athletico game into life and showed against Rangers that as well as all the mazy runs and tricks, he can finish too. Hugely impressive. Andrei Arshavin (8) floated on a higher plain, netting twice against Athletico (once outrageously) and wowing and delighting against Rangers. One through ball for Eduardo was one of the most outrageous you will ever see.
Eduardo (8) took his goal beautifully and looked razor sharp, while Bendtner (7) was industrious if unspectacular. RVP (6) can sometimes take time to warm-up going into the season.
Vermailen, Diaby and Nasri were all injured and Walcott and Gibbs and Vela were rested.